Skip to main navigation Skip to main content
Home

Search

  • Donate
  • News & opinion
  • About us
    • Who we are
      • Our vision, mission, values
      • Meet the NCB family
        • Anti-Bullying Alliance
        • Childhood Bereavement Network
        • Council for Disabled Children
        • Lambeth Early Action Partnership
        • Northern Ireland Anti-Bullying Forum
        • Schools' Wellbeing Partnership
      • Our story
      • Our process
      • NCB in Northern Ireland
        • Outcomes Based Accountability
        • NI projects & programmes
          • LINKS
            • LINKS Grant Holder Organisations
              • A - F
              • G - L
              • M - R
              • S - Z
            • LINKS workshops
            • LINKS Young People Advisory Group
            • LINKS Internship
            • LINKS News
            • LINKS Cluster Group Meetings
        • News & opinion
        • Resources & Publications
        • The Impact of Covid 19 on LINKS Groups
        • Involving Young People in Decision Making
        • Working with children & young people in NI
          • Children's rights work
          • Commission us for participation support
          • Participation Support Programme
          • Recent projects with children & young people
          • Supporting children & young people's right to participation
          • Young NCB Northern Ireland
          • Young researchers
        • Northern Ireland events
        • Northern Ireland newsletter
        • Contact the Northern Ireland team
      • Our people
        • Trustees
        • Leadership Team
        • Anti-Bullying Alliance
        • Childhood Bereavement Network
        • Communications and marketing
        • Council for Disabled Children
        • Corporate services
        • Digital
        • Early years
        • Education
        • Fundraising
        • Health
        • LEAP
        • Northern Ireland
        • Research and Policy
        • Participation
    • Where we work
    • Join the team
      • Current vacancies
      • Employee benefits
      • Working at NCB
    • Media centre
      • News & opinion
      • Spokespeople

    About us

    We bring people and organisations together to drive change in society and deliver a better childhood across the UK.

    More
    • Who we are
    • Where we work
    • Join the team
    • Media centre
    Featured

    Meet the NCB family

  • What we do
    • Research
      • Our research projects
      • Young Research Advisors
      • Research partners
      • Families Research Advisory Group
      • Research reports
    • Networks
    • Policy
      • All Party Parliamentary Group
      • Our manifesto
      • Policy campaigns
        • Build Back Childhood
        • Give us a Chancellor
        • A vision for recovery
        • Children at the Heart
      • Reports, briefings and consultation responses
      • Research and Policy newsletter
    • Practice
      • Developing effective social care services
        • Safeguarding Early Adopters
      • Early years
        • Early Childhood Unit
          • Our programmes
            • Making it REAL
            • Special Making it REAL
            • Education Endowment Foundation REAL RCT
            • Our work in Jersey
            • Our work in Lambeth
            • Our work in Lewisham
          • Our training
          • National Quality Improvement Network
          • Our resources
            • Early years leaflets
            • Knowledge Makes Change seminars
          • Early Childhood Unit newsletter
          • Our early years work in Northern Ireland
        • A Better Start
        • Early Years SEND Partnership
        • Lambeth Early Action Partnership
      • Health
        • Designated Medical / Clinical Officer role development
        • Expert Parent Programme
        • The role of Independent Reviewing Officers in England
      • Inclusion & SEND
        • Delivering Better Outcomes Together
        • Information, Advice and Support Programme
        • It’s My Life! Decisions, Capacity and Education, Health and Care Plans
      • Wellbeing & mental health
        • HeadStart
          • Schools
          • Community approaches
          • Cross systems working
          • Outputs
          • Participation and co-production
          • Workforce development
          • Digital
          • Vulnerable young people
          • Learning from events
          • Reflections from NCB Support and Development contract
        • Schools' Wellbeing Partnership
          • Whole school approach
          • Key resources
          • Recent partnership activity
          • Partnership members
          • Our forum
          • Apply to join the partnership
        • All Together: Whole-school anti-bullying programme
        • Award scheme recognises schools building better mental health
        • Get Your Rights website
        • Joining up the dots
        • Learn Equality, Live Equal
    • Participation
      • Young NCB
      • Recent projects with children & young people
      • Involving children & young people in research
      • Hear from the young people we work with
      • Join Young NCB
    • Our strategy

    What we do

    Our impact goes beyond childhood to deliver lasting change for future generations.

    More
    • Research
    • Networks
    • Policy
    • Practice
    • Participation
    • Our strategy
    Featured

    Give us a Chancellor

    Featured

    Reports, briefings and consultation responses

  • Resources
    • Events & training
      • Calendar
      • Training and consultancy
        • Early years training
    • Covid-19 resources
    • Resources for schools
    • Major reports
    • All resources

    Resources

    Information and tools to guide policy and practice development.

    More
    • Events & training
    • Covid-19 resources
    • Resources for schools
    • Major reports
    • All resources
    Featured

    Covid-19 resources

    Featured

    Resources for schools

  • Partner with us
    • Our impact
    • Trusts and foundations
    • Corporate partnerships
    • Individual fundraising
    • Donate
    • Annual reports
    • Shop
      • Memberships
        • Anti-Bullying Alliance membership
        • Childhood Bereavement Network membership
      • Tools and resources
        • Childhood Bereavement Network resources
        • Early Childhood Unit Resources

    Partner with us

    Get involved today to help us build a better childhood for every child.

    More
    • Our impact
    • Trusts and foundations
    • Corporate partnerships
    • Individual fundraising
    • Donate
    • Annual reports
    • Shop
    Featured

    Trusts and foundations

    Featured

    Donate

New analysis of help for struggling children and families underlines challenge facing Govt’s social care rethink

Image

Share

  • Share on facebook
  • Tweet this
  • Share linkedin
  • Email

Published

29 May 2021

Tags

Research - Social care & looked after children - News & opinion

The National Children’s Bureau and University of Cambridge have raised concerns that support for vulnerable children is being driven by what is easiest to measure, rather than deliver the community-based and family-orientated services envisioned in the Children Act.

‘Early Help’ is one element of support that services should make available to all families, and can help prevent children reaching a crisis where interventions by social workers are necessary.

NCB and Cambridge University have found convincing evidence that early help improves the lives of children and families, preventing unnecessary distress and harm which would require considerable extra expense to the public purse.

<<< READ THE REPORT >>>

However, a lack of a clear shared definition of early help, including little agreement over the thresholds for stepping in to provide support, means that measuring what works is difficult.

In the void, it has been difficult for local and national policy-makers to make the case for early help, leading to an overemphasis on ‘late intervention’ with families in the form of statutory social work investigations.

Researchers found the situation has been compounded by a decade of severe cuts to local authority budgets for children. Furthermore, national Government has shied away from tackling thorny issues like poverty and poor housing, which are often closely linked to family troubles.

The National Children’s Bureau is calling for:

  • A legal duty on local authorities and statutory safeguarding partners to provide early help to children and families. This should encompass a broad definition of early help, including support to alleviate the impact of poverty and poor housing.
  • The Department for Education should seek to reduce variations in thresholds for early help by providing clear guidance and training on assessing eligibility.
  • Government should develop a national outcomes framework for early help services, building on the work of the Supporting Families programme. This framework should be co-produced with children and families.
  • The Treasury should increase its funding in order to support implementation of this new duty, factoring in the levels of poverty within a local authority area.
  • The impact of these measures should be rigorously evaluated over a number of years. In particular, this evaluation should include use of routinely collected data from different services, to explore the outcomes for children and families receiving early help and social care interventions over time. 

Anna Feuchtwang, Chief Executive of the National Children Bureau, said:

‘If a doctor sees someone in pain, they step in immediately. Yet when it comes to vulnerable children and families, their suffering is allowed to fester. One of the central aims of the Children Act was to give a sense of urgency to authorities when they take action to protect the welfare of children as soon as they can. But progress has stalled, and funding cuts mean that services often let children and families’ lives spin out of control before doing anything. It’s time for a rethink of how we configure services – and that action starts with Government lifting the pressures on struggling families, and not ignoring factors like poor quality, over-crowded housing and poverty.’

Josh MacAlister, Chair of the Independent Review of Children's Social Care, said:

‘When parents need help to raise their children because they are caught in abusive relationships, because they are caring for disabled children or because they have an addiction, our response is too often to investigate rather than help. Too often our approach to families default towards the firm hand of safeguarding when more often the appropriate response would be an open hand of support. This report, and the evidence base it draws on, is a hugely welcome building block for the Independent Review of Children's Social Care and I look forward to working with the National Children's Bureau to learn more about their recommendations.’

This research is part of Living Assessments, a five–year research project on children’s health and social care funded by the Wellcome Trust in a partnership between NCB, University of Cambridge and University of Kent.

Definitions

Early help is a form of service-provision prior to Section 17 involvement, used by Working Together to Safeguard Children, and implies a focus on intervention before a challenge facing a family escalates to the point where statutory services are required.  Its philosophical basis is rooted in the 1971 reorganisation of personal social services based on recommendations from the Seebohm report, and later reaffirmed in the Children Act 1989. At their heart, was the idea that the “new local authority departments would be a community-based and family-orientated service which would be available to all”.

Prevention is a term similar to early help that is often used in public health policy; its use usually connotes more attention to proactive avoidance of potential problems than reactive assistance to alleviate problems that have already emerged. A preventative approach may emphasise reducing poverty or improving access to education, and such services may not therefore now always come under the remit of children’s services despite having ramifications for children’s social care.

Early intervention is a term that is often used interchangeably with ‘early help’, but has important differences in its historic development and associated evidence-base and approach. The history of research on early intervention is heavily informed by neuroscientific studies on the effects of neglect, attachment styles, and, later, Adverse Childhood Experiences, on the development of children’s brains.

‘Family support’ is a term often used to refer to community- and family-based practical and relational support, with a strong focus the social needs of families and how they are related to poverty and inequality.

About us

  • Who we are
  • Where we work
  • Join the team
  • Media centre
    • News & opinion
    • Spokespeople

Share

  • Share on facebook
  • Tweet this
  • Share linkedin
  • Email

Most Read

  • Rishi Sunak’s promise of new direction for children and families requires sustained investment

  • Northern Ireland Youth Forum (2)

  • Youth Initiatives

  • Youth Concern Whitehead

  • YouthAction NI

  • Women’s Aid ABCLN

You may also like

Social care — 3 Sep 2018

Storing up trouble - a postcode lottery of children's social care

More
Our research projects — 15 Dec 2019

Living Assessments

Understanding the experiences and impact of health and social care assessments on children and families.

More
Back to top
Home

Sign up to our newsletter

  • About us
    • Who we are
    • Where we work
    • Join the team
    • Media centre
  • What we do
    • Research
    • Networks
    • Policy
    • Practice
    • Participation
    • Our strategy
  • Resources
    • Events & training
    • Covid-19 resources
    • Resources for schools
    • Major reports
    • All resources
  • Partner with us
    • Our impact
    • Trusts and foundations
    • Corporate partnerships
    • Individual fundraising
    • Donate
    • Annual reports
    • Shop

Meet the NCB family : United for better childhood

  • NCB Home

  • CDC Home

  • CBN Home

  • ABA Home

  • SWP Home

© National Children's Bureau 2022

  • linkedin
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy statement
  • Terms and conditions
  • Cookie Policy
  • Suppliers area
  • Contact us

Registered charity No. 258825. Registered in England and Wales No. 952717.

Registered office: National Children’s Bureau, 23 Mentmore Terrace, Hackney, London E8 3PN. A Company Limited by Guarantee.

Site by Effusion