Translating ambition into investment and integration: NCB response to Milburn Review

The Milburn Review's proposals, including a Youth Opportunity Service and Opportunity Guarantee, could be transformative. But only if they are backed by genuine cross-government action, early intervention and coordinated support for young people facing the greatest barriers.

The Milburn Review is right to challenge a system that spends far more responding to the consequences of economic inactivity than preventing it. If managed correctly, it is right to shift investment towards support, participation and opportunity for young people. The crucial question now is how that ambition translates into real investment in services and support, particularly for the young people facing the greatest barriers. 

The real test of these reforms will be whether they improve outcomes for young people whose lives sit at the intersection of multiple systems, including disabled children and young people and those with special educational needs (SEND), mental health needs, care experience, and involvement in the justice system. 

Contact with each of these systems significantly increases the chances a young person will end up not in education, employment or training (NEET)*. 

We also know that six in ten NEET young people experienced poverty growing up, so continuing efforts to reduce child poverty are an essential foundation of the review’s long-term goals^.  

The review proposes a Youth Opportunity Service, a legal Opportunity Guarantee, and new duties across health and local systems designed to improve participation. These proposals have the potential to be transformative, but only if they create genuine integration between education, health, welfare, employment and social care services at a time when each of these systems are undergoing significant reforms.  

Many young people facing the greatest barriers are not reached by services until disengagement has set in, and when they are, the support is too often fragmented and not focused on getting them into work or learning. 

Too many services then fall away around their 18th birthday, with nothing to trigger re-engagement. Extending the Youth Opportunity Service to age 24 mirrors the way the SEND system extends support beyond the traditional cut-off for children’s services, and is a chance to close that gap.  

The government’s response must focus not only on how traditional 'children’s' services can join up better, but how the state can bridge this crucial gap to support young people as they enter adulthood. 

Young people themselves must also be at the centre of implementation, helping to shape how new services are designed and delivered in their local communities. 

Achieving a ‘whole system reset’ will require a genuine life-course approach that starts long before a young person becomes NEET.

That means tackling poverty, supporting children's health and wellbeing, meeting SEND needs early, strengthening school belonging, and ensuring children and families can access timely support from the services around them. 

NCB's work consistently demonstrates that outcomes in early adulthood are shaped by experiences throughout childhood, from the early years onwards, and that preventative support is essential to improving participation in later life.  

There also remain important questions about how proposed changes to financial support would work in practice, and what their long-term impact would be for disabled young people, or those with additional needs. 

As government considers its response, it must ensure that efforts to increase participation do not fundamentally compromise financial security.  

The government now needs to set out what steps it will take to integrate the recommendations and messages of the review of the report into its children’s social care, SEND, and health reforms, as well as the mental health strategy, and the devolution agenda, where the review gives strategic authorities a central role.  

Changes are needed if these reforms are to collectively build a system that wraps support around children and young people from early years through to adulthood. 

NCB will continue to work with government and local partners, as well as young people themselves, to help ensure reforms are integrated across local services and are shaped by evidence and lived experience. 

 

* The review evidences the link between NEET status and care experience and SEND (paragraph 370), and mental health needs (paragraph 190). Evidence on the link with involvement in the youth justice system is available from Youth Futures Foundation. 

^ According to analysis commissioned by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Trussell.